THE BUZZ
SEG International (SEGi) has received a notice of
unconditional takeover offer from Navis Capital through the latter’s
fully-owned subsidiary Pinnacle Heritage Solutions SB (PHS) which currently
holds a
27.8% stake in SEGi. The offer is pegged at a price of RM1.714 per share and RM1.214 per
outstanding warrant.
OUR TAKE
Sequence of the entire saga. To recap, Navis Capital
emerged as the single second largest shareholder in SEGi after its fully-owned
subsidiary PHS took up 148.5m shares and 61.1m warrants early this month at
RM1.71/share and RM1.21/warrant respectively. This makes Navis Capital’s stake
in SEGi second only to Dato’ Sri Clement Hii who held 158.9m shares and 76.2m
warrants back then. Nonetheless, Navis Capital has acquired another 18.0m
warrants from Dato’ Sri Clement Hii yesterday in an off-market transaction,
putting itself on the brink of becoming the single largest shareholder in SEGi with
its total investment in SEGi now standing at RM349.6m. Upon the full conversion
of all outstanding warrants and excluding existing treasury shares of 26.0m,
Navis Capital’s stake in SEGi works out to be 31.5%, while Dato’ Seri Clement
Hii would in turn hold 30.0% of the company.
Shareholders’
agreement between the two parties. Following the acquisition of the said warrants, PHS had entered into a
shareholder’s agreement with Dato’ Sri Clement Hii to regulate the rights and
obligations of both parties as shareholders of SEGi. And as a consequence of
the agreement, the two parties which hold a combined 57.6% stake in SEGi (or an
effective 61.5% upon the full conversion of warrants) triggered a Mandatory General Offer (MGO) on SEGi. With that, PHS proposed
to acquire all the remaining 226.0m shares
(ex-treasury shares of 26.0m) and 52.0m warrants in SEGi not held by PHS
and Dato’ Sri Clement Hii currently at RM1.714 per share and RM1.214 per warrant
respectively. This brings the MGO cost to as much as RM450.4m, assuming full acceptances
on both shares and outstanding warrants by minority shareholders.
Unattractive pricing.
In our previous report, we highlighted that
any privatization offer has to be priced at a minimum of RM2.10/share to
entice the minority shareholders. The final offer of RM1.714/share is on par
with Navis Capital’s entrance cost but fell short of our expectations and it is
at a significant 5.3% discount (instead of premium) to its last closing of
RM1.81. Given the unappealing MGO
valuation which translates into 14.2x FY12 PER and 12.9x FY13 PER based
on a fully enlarged share base vis-à-vis our FV of RM2.17 at 18x FY12 PER, we
advise minorities to reject the offer.
Source: OSK188
How do shareholders reject the offer and even then doesn't the majority decides?
ReplyDelete